30 Pie Recipes We Can’t Resist

These 30 pie recipes are too delicious to resist. From savory to sweet, I have all the bases covered.

Buttery pastry? Check. Sweet and savory fillings? Check.

If you’re not drooling by the end of this list, you might want to see a doctor.

Of course, the classics made the list. Blueberry, cherry, pecan, and sweet potato- they’re all here.

But there are tasty creations that you may not know, like chess pie, millionaire pie, and shoo fly pie.

So grab your favorite pie dish and roll up those sleeves. It’s time to check out these fantastic pie recipes.

1. Brownie Pie

It’s kind of amazing what adding buttery pie crust can do to a good brownie!

With this recipe, the light pie crust helps to mellow that rich chocolate flavor just a little. 

It also gives you the chance to add a layer of caramel under the brownie that will turn gooey as the whole thing bakes.

2. Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie

Buttermilk pie is a southern twist on the classic British egg custard.

The main difference is that we use buttermilk instead of heavy cream for a lovely tangy flavor.

The creamy custard filling with a buttery pie crust is divine.

It gives serious creme brulee vibes. But you don’t need to be an expert baker to pull off this sweet pie recipe.

3. Cherry Pie with Cherry Pie Filling

I’ve tried canned fillings, but they aren’t always great. Some can be pretty flavorless and not sweet enough for my palate. 

My advice would be to try out a few until you find one you like, and then modify it to make it perfect. 

This recipe is a great way to jazz up store-bought ingredients to taste homemade!

4. No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie

When it comes to no-bake pies, you really can’t go wrong with peanut butter and chocolate. 

You’ll more or less make a simple cheesecake filling (without the eggs), beating the cream cheese until completely smooth, and then adding in the sugar and peanut butter.

This mix is super dense and creamy, and would make an excellent pie filling as is. 

5. Cinnamon Roll Apple Pie

Who knew apple pies could be even more delicious? Sweet pie recipes don’t always have to be so tedious and time-consuming.

Premade cinnamon rolls work as a crust (so no tedious crust-making!). Top it with apple pie filling, and a streusel crumble on top. 

Seriously, you have to try this recipe!

6. Bisquick Cheeseburger Pie

I suppose you could call this a quiche or a tart, but let’s not split hairs. As long as it’s tasty, it gets a spot on the list.

And boy, is it tasty! It captures the flavors of a cheeseburger in pie form.

This recipe is crazy easy to make and can be on your table in less than 30 minutes. 

7. Triple Coconut Cream Pie

Looking for a no-bake treat this summer? Then let me introduce you to triple coconut cream pie!

Not only is it simple, but it doesn’t shy away from yummy coconut flavors. It piles 2 layers of coconut pudding and whipped cream in a graham cracker crust. 

Oh, and don’t forget the shredded coconut on top!

8. Pumpkin Pie

I don’t know about you, but I get that pumpkin spice craving year-round.

So much so that I actively cook, puree, and freeze pumpkin during fall to make this pie in the spring.

Deep-dish pie crusts are a must for pumpkin pies since they give you so much more filling to enjoy. 

9. Vegan Lemon Meringue Pie

One bite of this, and you’ll call me a liar. No way is it vegan!

I was blown away by the zesty filling, which is super bright, flavorful, and nice and sturdy. But it’s the meringue that gets me!

What is essentially chickpea juices somehow magically whips up just like real egg whites. 

And no, it doesn’t taste like chickpeas!

10. Millionaire Pie

If you’re looking for something a little different, something you don’t usually see at summer BBQs, this one’s for you!

The base of the filling is a blend of cream cheese, condensed milk, and lemon juice. So it’s creamy, tangy, and not overly sweet. 

To this, you’ll add a whole (drained) can of crushed pineapples, some maraschino cherries, and a few chopped pecans. 

11. Tomato Pie

Unlike some tomato quiche recipes that ask you to chop up a few cherry tomatoes and stir them into the egg custard, this recipe uses big thick slices and lots of them!

It’s thick and flavorful (thanks to fresh herbs), and oh-so-cheesy!

Seriously, that tomato and cheese filling with a crispy crust is amazing.

12. Easy Homemade Chicken Pot Pie

Making chicken pot pie can be a chore. And savory pie recipes are often very tedious.

However, you can save oodles of time with this recipe. It all comes together in just 30 minutes and tastes fantastic.

The insides are thick and meaty and bursting with flavor. But the best part here is the Bisquick top layer.

There’s no rolling pin required!

13. Banana Cream Pie

Banana cream pie is the stuff of dreams. It’s luscious, sweet, creamy, and impossible to resist. 

This recipe is all of that, plus it’s vegan and gluten-free.

That crumbly graham cracker crust paired with banana pudding is amazing. It’s creamy and dreamlike and gets a banana boost from fresh bananas on top

14. Dream Whip Chocolate Cream Pie

Dream Whip is like instant pudding, but it’s basically Cool Whip flavor. 

When that rainy day comes, nothing is better than this rich chocolate pie! It needs just five ingredients and 20 minutes of your time.

It comes together so easily, and your family will go crazy over this insanely silky pie.

15. Texas Pecan Pie

In the pie Hall of Fame, pecan pie lands near the top. 

Pecan pie originated in Texas, so you know this recipe does it justice!  It’s sweet, nutty, crunchy, and ooey-gooey. Bring it to your next holiday party, and watch it steal the show. 

And the best part? Everything comes together in a little over an hour. Pure perfection.

16. Chess Pie

Chess pie is one of those very old recipes that’s stood the test of time. Dating back to the late 1800’s, there’s a reason it hung around. 

That flakey, buttery crust with a creamy custard filling just melts in your mouth. 

My favorite part is the crispy crust that’s oh-so-sweet and buttery.

17. Banoffee Pie Recipe

Banoffee pie is a scrumptious mix of bananas, caramel, and whipped cream. 

It usually has a digestive biscuit base and a thick caramel filling made using condensed milk (dulce de leche). 

Graham crackers will work too, but not pastry as it needs to be something crumbly. Even chocolate chip cookies will work if they’re crisp.

18. Super Easy S’mores Chocolate Pie

This specific recipe has a gooey, chocolate filling which is essentially chocolate ganache – chocolate and heavy cream.

The more chocolate you add, the firmer the filling will be. 

For that authentic s’more taste, a Graham cracker crust is mandatory. But if you want it even more intense, feel free to use an Oreo crust. 

19. Key Lime Pie

Now here’s a pie that’s ready for summer. It’s a great potluck dessert that’s light and airy and not overly sweet. 

This recipe for key lime pie strikes that ideal balance between sweet and tangy. 

The secret ingredient for that incredibly smooth filling i

20. Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie

Gather round, strawberry rhubarb skeptics! One bite of this amazing pie, and you’ll suddenly understand what the fuss is all about. 

It’s a simple, straightforward recipe that lets the strawberries and rhubarb do the talking. 

Strawberries bring the sweetness, and rhubarb delivers a subtle sourness. They’re a match made in pie heaven.

21. Caramel Pie

If you love caramel as much as I do, you have to try this easy pie recipe!

It combines a flakey, buttery all-butter pie crust with a silky smooth caramel filling. 

What’s great about this recipe is it’s a blank slate for tasty toppings like whipped cream, chopped nuts, or chocolate. Because caramel goes with everything!

22. Mississippi Mud Pie

Crazy about chocolate? Then you’ve come to the right place! It’s the best pie recipe for all those chocolate lovers.

With a buttery Oreo crust, chewy brownie layer chocolate pudding layer, you’ll need a nap after one slice!

But it’s not all chocolate. Adding homemade whipped cream on top take this pie over the edge.

23. Spinach and Cheese Hand Pies

Hand pies, empanadas, pasties, pastry pockets, no matter what you call them, they’re simple to make and such a treat. 

This savory pie recipe is a classic, using spinach and cheese along with garlic and herbs for an added boost.

It’s a similar texture to a spinach dip since you’ll use ricotta and cream cheese. 

24. Tamale Pie

Tamale pie captures the flavor of tamales without the fuss of wrapping and rolling. 

The inside is incredibly meaty and cheesey with just the right amount of spice. 

No talame is complete without the cornbread! Adding a layer of boxed corn muffin mix on top creates the perfect (and easy) crust.

25. Shepherd’s Pie

This quick recipe is here to make your weeknights easier and your belly full.

It’s a sneaky way to get the family to eat their veggies. The meaty filling incorporates plenty of veggies, and that cheesy potato crust is drool-worthy.

It’s comfort food at its finest and comes together in a snap. What’s not to love?

26. Kentucky Derby Pie

Think of Kentucky Derby pie as a chocolatey pecan pie. Do I even need to go on?

It piles a sticky, chocolatey pecan layer in a flakey pie crust. The top layer crisps to golden perfection in the oven while the insides stay nice and gooey. 

Garnish with whipped cream, and watch your family go a little crazy over this decadent pie.

27. Cranberry Apple Slab Pie

Never heard of slab pie before? It’s a rustic pie that’s super simple and tastes amazing!

Think of it like easy-peasy hand pies.

The crust is so buttery and flakey, and that tart cranberry apple filling takes it over the top.

It’s the perfect dessert for potlucks, or holiday gatherings when you want to impress.

28. Shoo Fly Pie

Shoo fly pie has it all! A flaky crust, gooey center, and buttery crumble topping. 

This pie primarily uses brown sugar and molasses, so you know the flavors are rich and decedent. 

The gooey center melts in your mouth, while the crumble topping gives a nice contrast of textures.

29. Sweet Potato Pie

Sweet potato pie is a holiday classic for a good reason. It’s delicately spiced, and oh-so-buttery. 

The sweet potatoes deliver a silky smooth sweetness accent by cinnamon and nutmeg. 

Think of it as sweet potato custard in a flaky pie crust. Is your mouth watering yet? This pie is perfect for the holidays!

30. Blueberry Pie Recipe

In my humble opinion, blueberry pie is the king of fruity pies.

Though you can use frozen berries, I highly recommend using fresh ones if you can.

It’s perfectly sweet with a kiss of tartness from the blueberries. And that lattice top makes it look oh-so-scrumptious! Nothing says summer like blueberry pie.