Home â€ș Articles â€ș 10 Best Old Bay Seasoning Substitutes

10 Best Old Bay Seasoning Substitutes

If you’re on the hunt for Old Bay Seasoning substitutes, you’re in luck!

Plenty of different spices and blends will give your food a similar flavor profile – you just have to know where to look!

10 Best Old Bay Seasoning Substitutes

This classic Maryland spice blend is a must for crab boils. But it’s also great on shrimp, fish, and – surprise, surprise – chicken!

If you love it as much as I do, chances are you’ve run out once or twice.

And when you’re in the middle of cooking, you can’t just drop everything to go shopping.

Fortunately, these Old Bay Seasoning substitutes have you covered.

What is Old Bay Seasoning? 

Old Bay Seasoning is a spice blend that typically includes:

  • Celery salt
  • Paprika
  • Pepper
  • Red pepper
  • Cloves
  • Allspice
  • Cardamom
  • Bay leaves
  • Mace
  • Nutmeg
  • Ginger
  • Cinnamon
  • Mustard
  • Ground celery seed

With all of that good stuff, it’s no wonder people love it

Created in Baltimore, which we know is famous for seafood, you’ll see a few different recipes for Old Bay.

So, unfortunately, from one can to the next, the ingredients list changes.

It’s probably because the Old Bay folks aren’t keen on giving up their secret recipe. They’re like Mr. Krabs in that respect.

What we do know is that the seasoning mix includes a ton of flavorful, fragrant ingredients. And those listed above are in almost every recipe!

What Is Old Bay Seasoning Used For?

Honestly, the easier question might be: What can’t you use Old Bay Seasoning for?

Because the list of things you can use it for is pretty extensive! 

Old Bay Seasoning can be used as a rub or marinade for meats and seafood or as a seasoning for rice, chips, pasta, potatoes, and more.

You can add it to chili, grilled veggies, or various BBQ dishes and sides. It even tastes great in vegan recipes or in deviled, scrambled, or fried eggs.

I like it on my breakfast hash or in a creamy chicken salad sandwich.

So, like I said, you can put this stuff into and on anything.

Top 10 Substitutes for Old Bay Seasoning

 Copycat Old Bay Seasoning 

1. Homemade Old Bay Seasoning 

The best way to substitute Old Bay is with Old Bay. Or, at least, as close to it as you’ll get.

After all, running out of Old Bay is a bummer. But if you make a big batch of this homemade recipe, you won’t have to worry.

Of all the options on this list, this stuff tastes the most like the real thing. So you can use it in any recipe that calls for Old Bay.

Of course, it also takes a little work, and you need all the individual ingredients on hand. 

And because the Old Bay Seasoning people won’t share their secrets, I don’t have an exact recipe.

But this one from Tastylicious is the closest I’ve ever found.

Here are the ingredients:

  • 1 1/2 tablespoon celery salt
  • 1/8 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1/8 teaspoon cayenne
  • 1/8 teaspoon mustard
  • 1/4 teaspoon paprika
  • A pinch each of the following:
    • Ginger
    • Cinnamon
    • Nutmeg
    • Cloves
    • Cardamom
    • Allspice

Use ground spices, or grind them yourself with a mortar and pestle. Either way, you’ll mix them and store them somewhere cool and dry.

It may not be the real thing, but it’s close enough!

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1 teaspoon of the homemade blend.

Paprika on a Wooden Dish

2. Paprika and Celery Salt

Celery salt is the biggest component of Old Bay Seasoning. And paprika falls right behind it.

So, if you have those two things, you’ll have a decent Old Bay dupe.

Most websites say to mix them in equal parts (1/4 teaspoon of each). However, I feel a bit of extra celery salt gets even closer to the real thing. 

And if you like, add cayenne or red pepper flakes for extra bite.

From there, you can use it in any recipe that calls for Old Bay. It won’t have the same depth, but it’s better than nothing!

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with a generous, heaping 1/4 teaspoon of celery salt + a level 1/4 teaspoon of paprika.

Cajun Seasoning Spilled from a Tablespoon

3. Cajun Seasoning 

One could argue that Old Bay Seasoning is a type of Cajun seasoning. After all, people probably use it most often in Creole and Cajun dishes

With that in mind, Cajun seasoning makes a terrific substitute.

Most blends include paprika, pepper, and other prominent Old Bay spices. And the only significant difference is that Cajun also includes cayenne.

That gives it more heat than Old Bay, so start slow and add it in small increments.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1/2 teaspoon of Cajun seasoning. Add more as needed.

Wooden Spoon With Sesame Seeds For Crab Boil Ingredients

4. Crab Boil 

Cajun, Crab Boil, and Old Bay are all pretty similar. They combine various herbs and spices and use many of the same ingredients. 

For example, Crab Boil includes celery (seed instead of salt) and paprika. That makes it an excellent replacement for Old Bay at a one-to-one ratio. 

Crab Boil is slightly sweeter than Old Bay, but it’s not that noticeable in most dishes.

Also, it’s meant explicitly for seafood, so it works best in those recipes.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1 teaspoon of crab boil.

Seasoned Salt on Top of a White Table

5. Seasoned Salt + Celery Salt

Most seasoned salt varieties don’t include celery salt. So, they don’t taste precisely like Old Bay.

Still, if you want a delicious rub, seasoned salt is a good option.

It has a wonderful flavor and smells incredible. It’s even salty and herby, like Old Bay. 

Also, like Old Bay, seasoned salt is perfect for a wide range of recipes. You can use it for meat or in omelets, sandwiches, and roasted veggies.

Finally, if you add celery salt, it’ll be a pretty close match to Old Bay.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1/2 teaspoon of seasoned salt + 1/2 teaspoon of celery salt.

Pickling Spice on a Black Bowl

6. Pickling Spice 

Pickling spice is similar to Old Bay because it uses many herbs and spices.

Typically, there’s ginger, bay leaves, allspice, salt, red pepper, mustard, and more.

Because it has such diverse ingredients, it replicates Old Bay’s complexity very well. Better yet, you can find pickling spice at practically any grocery store. 

It works best in seafood dishes, but you can use it in anything.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1 teaspoon of pickling spice.

Bowl of Spices and Seasonings: Cajun and Pumpkin Spice

7. Salt and Pepper Seasoning

Plain old salt and pepper will never replace Old Bay Seasoning’s wealth of flavor.

But salt and pepper seasoning is something else! It’s a fun and punchy blend that came to promenance in Chinese takeaway shops in the U.K.

Salt & pepper chips (fries) are life-changing, and it’s all down to this blend.

Here’s what you’ll need:

  • 1 teaspoon sea salt
  • 1 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1 teaspoon chilli flakes
  • 1/2 teaspoon Chinese 5-spice
  • 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground ginger
  • 1 teaspoon caster sugar

That mix is salty, spicy, a little sweet, and plenty bold. It might not be as bold as Old Bay, but I highly recommend trying it.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1 teaspoon of salt and pepper seasoning.

White Pepper on a Small Ball as Ingredients for French Four Spice

8. French Four Spice

The white pepper in French Four Spice lays an excellent foundation for an Old Bay replacement.

The spice blend also contains cloves, ginger, and nutmeg, all of which are found in Old Bay.

Those four ingredients make French Four Spice an adequate substitute. However, you’ll want to add a few things to make it even better

Start with the French spice as a base. Then, add:

  • 1/8 teaspoon red pepper flakes
  • 1/8 teaspoon paprika
  • 1/8 – 1/4 teaspoon celery salt

Together, they make a close replica of your favorite seafood spice blend.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1 teaspoon of the modifed French Four spice blend.

Chili Powder, Garlic Powder & Celery Salt on a Square Bowl

9. Chili Powder, Garlic Powder & Celery Salt 

Although this mixture isn’t perfect, it’s a decent replacement.

Simply use 1/4 teaspoon of each ingredient for every required teaspoon of Old Bay.

It won’t be precisely the same, but it hits the major flavor highlights. 

The chili powder adds heat, while the garlic brings the herby earthiness. And the celery salt is, well, celery salt – the main ingredient of Old Bay!

This mixture works best in stews, soups, sauces, and – surprisingly – on chicken.

Of course, you can also use it in seafood, but other options here work better for that.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 14 teaspoon of chili powder + 1/4 teaspoon of garlic powder + 1/4 teaspoon of celery salt.

Chinese Five Star

10. Chinese Five Star

I’m putting Chinese Five Star (or Five Spice) near the bottom of the list because it doesn’t taste like Old Bay Seasoning. 

It uses several spices and herbs, but they’re very different from the ones in Old Bay. These include star anise, cinnamon, fennel, etc.

It has significantly more sweetness in it than Old Bay, too. So, if you’re looking for a close replacement for the seasoning, it won’t work. 

All that said, if you just want something flavorful to spice up your food, give it a try.

How to Substitute: Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1/2 teaspoon of Chinese Five spice blend. Add more as needed.

Other Seasoning Substitutes To Keep On Hand

Substitutes for Tarragon
Nutmeg Substitutes
Substitutes for Red Pepper Flakes
Chipotle Powder Substitutes

Old Bay Seasoning Substitute

Cuisine: American
Servings

1

serving
Prep time

5

minutes
Total time

5

minutes

If you’re on the hunt for Old Bay Seasoning substitutes, you’re in luck! Plenty of different spices and blends will give your food the same flavor profile.

Ingredients

  • Option 1 – (Best Overall) Homemade Old Bay Seasoning
  • 1 1/2 tablespoon 1 1/2 celery salt

  • 1/8 teaspoon 1/8 black pepper

  • 1/8 teaspoon 1/8 cayenne

  • 1/8 teaspoon 1/8 mustard seeds

  • 1/4 teaspoon 1/4 paprika

  • 1 pinch 1 each ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, cardamom, and allspice

  • Option 2 – (Easiest Swap) Paprika and Celery Salt
  • heaping 1/4 teaspoon celery salt

  • 1/4 teaspoon 1/4 paprika

Instructions

  • (Best Overall) Homemade Old Bay Seasoning
  • Add the celery salt, black pepper, cayenne, mustard seeds, paprika, ginger, cinamon, nutmeg, cloves, cardamom, and allspice to a mortar and pestle or a coffee grinder.
  • Grind or blitz until the spices are evenly ground and well distributed.
  • Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with 1 teaspoon of the homemade blend.
  • (Easiest Swap) Paprika and Celery Salt
  • Swap 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning with a generous, heaping 1/4 teaspoon of celery salt + a level 1/4 teaspoon of paprika.
Old Bay Seasoning Substitutes

Did you like the recipe?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 1

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Thanks!

Share on social media:

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

INSANELYGOOD

Hey there! I'm Kim. I love running, cooking, and curling up with a good book! I share recipes for people who LOVE good food, but want to keep things simple :)

Leave a Comment