Home Desserts 25 Butterfinger Desserts You’ll Go Nuts For

25 Butterfinger Desserts You’ll Go Nuts For

Can you think of anything better than Butterfinger desserts? I know I can’t!

Rich, chocolatey, and loaded with nutty goodness, they’re too indulgent to resist.

25 Butterfinger Desserts You’ll Go Nuts For featuring Cream Cheese and Butterfinger Trifle
Enter your email below & we'll send it straight to your inbox.

The perfect mixture of sweet, flakey, and buttery, Butterfingers are the ideal accompaniment for any dessert recipe.

We’ve got everything from ice cream, cookies, cake, and even nachos right here. And each treat is better than the last.  

Trust me, this list of 25 Butterfinger desserts will satisfy any sweet tooth.

1. Butterfinger Chocolate and Peanut Butter Lush

Okay, we’re starting strong with this Butterfinger chocolate and peanut butter lush. 

This dessert has layers of creamy, chocolatey goodness, combined with the sweet buttery crunch of the crowd-pleasing chocolate bar. 

It’s crazy-easy to make and even easier to devour!

2. Chewy Butterfinger Cookies

If you prefer to consume your favorite chocolate bar in cookie form, this recipe will be a home run.

Each cookie is chewy and melts in your mouth.

It’s like a chocolate chip cookie but so much better. 

3. Butterfinger Scotcheroos 

These Butterfinger Scotcheroos are a great no-bake bar recipe that will make waves at the next bake sale.

They’re chewy, sticky, and oh-so-chocolatey. It’ll be hard to have just one, so go ahead and have another (I won’t tell anyone!).

4. Butterfinger Cookie Bars

Okay, how great do these Butterfinger cookie bars look? 

Each square starts with a cookie base with chopped Butterfinger bits interspersed. 

Enter your email below & we'll send it straight to your inbox.

Then, they’re topped with a creamy, mouth-watering Butterfinger icing to create one heavenly sweet treat.

5. Butterfinger Poke Cake

Never had a poke cake before? Allow me to explain!

As the name suggests, a poke cake is a cake with holes poked into it.

You fill these holes with chocolate or pudding, or in the case of this tantalizing cake, caramel, and sweetened condensed milk. 

This cake, in particular, has an extra level of sweetness with bits of Butterfinger crumbled on top. Delish!

6. Butterfinger Ice Cream 

If you’re an ice cream lover like I am, then you’ll become obsessed with this Butterfinger ice cream after just one bite.

Every mouthful is creamy, crunchy, chocolatey, and buttery.

This ice cream would shine in a waffle cone or when served in a banana split for an extra special treat. 

I’ll be smooshing it between two of those chewy Butterfinger cookies to create homemade ice cream sandwiches. 

7. Gooey Butterfinger Brownie Bars

It might seem impossible to make the classic brownie any better, but this recipe does just that.

These gooey Butterfinger brownie bars are chewy, rich, peanut-y, and brimming with rich chocolate flavor. 

Each bar is a luscious little square of heaven that you might not want to share.

8. Reese’s Butterfinger Cream Cheese Trifle

Here’s the dynamic duo you never knew you needed.

Butterfinger, meet Reese’s. Together, the two candy bars create one tasty dessert!

Not only does this cream cheese trifle look pretty, but it’s also sinfully delicious. Plus, it comes together with little effort, and the payoff is huge.

9. Butterfinger Bundt Cake 

If you have some extra Butterfingers lying around from Halloween, put them to good use with this decadent dessert recipe.

To make this treat, cover the dense cake with cream cheese icing and sprinkle some crushed Butterfingers on top. 

This cake makes the perfect finale for any dinner party. Your guests will thank you later.

10. Easy No Bake Butterfinger Pie

How great does this Butterfinger pie look? 

Did I mention it only takes ten minutes to prep and uses only four ingredients? Yeah, you read that right.

If you’re looking for a delectable treat to whip up in a snap, this recipe is the one for you. 

11. Butterfinger Pumpkin Stuffed Donuts 

Get ready for the best crossover of the fall season.

Butterfingers and pumpkin spice go together like two peas in a pod. 

This recipe makes a great treat when the leaves turn brown and the weather gets chilly.

Be sure to have your cappuccino on hand to dip these donuts into!

12. Peanut Butter Butterfinger Cheesecake

If you’re a cheesecake lover, then you’ll adore this dessert. 

Between the luscious cheesecake base, creamy peanut butter, and crushed Butterfingers, what’s not to love? 

I know I’ll be serving this up at my next Easter dinner. Serve with some coffee on the side for an irresistible treat. 

13. Butterfinger Monster Cookies 

This cookie has it all: peanut butter oats, chocolate chips, M&M’s, and Butterfinger, all rolled up into one unique cookie.

Each bite oozes with chocolatey, peanut-y sweetness, making this one oh-so-sinful treat. 

If you like your cookies loaded with everything but the kitchen sink, be sure to take this recipe for a spin. 

14. Butterfinger® Cookie Dough Bites 

Does it get any better than these Butterfinger cookie dough bites? 

If you like cookies a little undercooked (read: sinfully chewy), then these cookie dough bites will rock your world.

They’re crunchy and tender with a delectable chocolate coating. Plus, they’re super simple yet look incredibly effective.

I like to make these over the holidays to give out as gifts, and they’re always a hit.

15. Butterfinger Fudge

Using only four ingredients, you can create the fudge of your dreams!

This recipe is a fabulous way to use up any excess candy corn you have lying around the house after Halloween. 

So, if you’re sick of candy but want something sweet, you have to try this fudge.

It’s a creamy, sugary treat that will soothe any sweet tooth. 

16. Butterfinger Bark 

If peppermint bark feels a little been-there-done-that, give this Butterfinger bark a try.

It’s crunchy, chocolatey, and each nibble melts in your mouth. 

I’ve handed this out on Halloween to plenty of smiling faces, and it even makes a great party favor too!

17. Keto Butterfinger Mug Cake 

If you’re looking for a sweet dessert on the keto diet, then this Butterfinger mug cake should do the trick.

It uses almond flour to simulate a fluffy cake that won’t break the carb bank. And Erythritol guarantees something sweet.

18. Butterfinger Blondies

Looking for something thick, chewy, and insanely delicious? These Butterfinger blondies are ideal for any occasion.

I love blondies for their texture and chewiness, and these Butterfinger blondies give you all that and more!

19. Peanut Butter Butterfinger Dip

I’m all about dessert dips these days. They make such an easy crowd-pleaser, and they’re especially terrific if you need something last minute.

Serve with Graham Crackers, apple slices, and even buttery Ritz crackers. The options are endless for this peanut butter Butterfinger dip.  

20. Butterfinger Candy Popcorn

Move over movie theatre popcorn; there’s a new sheriff in town.

One bite of this Butterfinger candy concoction, and it’ll be hard to go back to plain old popcorn.

If the movie theatres served up this sensational snack, we’d all pay for a double feature!

21. Butterfinger Caramel Bars 

These Butterfinger caramel bars combine everything you want in a sugary treat: marshmallows, Butterfingers, chocolate, and Graham Crackers.

Put it all together, and you’ve got one tasty camping dessert. It resembles s’mores but tastes more buttery and chocolatey. 

22. Butterfinger Rice Krispie Treats

Want to shake up your standard Rice Krispie Treat recipe? Then read on!

These Butterfinger Rice Krispie Treats are chewy and sweet but contain chocolatey, peanut-y goodness.

It elevates the school bake sale staple to a whole new level.

23. Butterfinger S’mores Bars

You can’t make these s’mores over an open fire, but they taste like a night under the stars. 

These bad boys are full of sugary, chocolatey sweetness. One bite of these bars, and you’ll never go back to regular s’mores. 

24. Butterfinger Caramel Apple Nachos

If you need the perfect recipe for the kid’s Halloween party, I’ve got you covered.

Introducing dessert nachos!

They’re like regular nachos but use apple slices instead of chips, chocolate syrup instead of salsa, and Butterfinger pieces instead of your usual fixings. 

This recipe creates a fun finger food that will absolutely be a hit!

25. Peanut Butter Blossoms 

Peanut butter blossoms are a time-old recipe I always come back to!

The cookie’s chewiness blends perfectly with the softness of the chocolate, and they have such a nostalgic quality.

But now it’s time to take the classic recipe and revamp it a bit.

Instead of adding plain chocolate to the center, consider adding a piece of Butterfinger to add a wow factor. 

25 Butterfinger Dessert Recipe Collection

Can you think of anything better than Butterfinger desserts? I know I can’t! Rich, chocolatey, and loaded with nutty goodness, they’re too indulgent to resist.


  • Select your favorite recipe.
  • Organize all the required ingredients.
  • Prep a delicious recipe in 30 minutes or less!
Butter Finger Desserts

Did you like the recipe?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 1

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.


Share on social media:

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

author avatar
Kim - InsanelyGood
Hey there! I'm Kim. I love running, cooking, and curling up with a good book! I share recipes for people who LOVE good food, but want to keep things simple :)

Leave a Comment